Reply to the comments by Pillai, S. P., George, B. G., Ray, J. S., and Kale, V. S., (GJ-19-0112) on Paper: “Depositional history and provenance of cratonic “Purana” basins in southern India: A multipronged geochronology approach to the Proterozoic Kaladgi and Bhima basins” by Joy et al., 2018

Authors

Sojen Joy, De Beers Group
Sarbani Patranabis-Deb, Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata
Dilip Saha, Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata
Hielke Jelsma, De Beers Group
Roland Maas, University of Melbourne
Ulf Söderlund, Lunds Universitet
Sebastian Tappe, De Beers Group
Gert van der Linde, De Beers Group
Amlan Banerjee, Indian Statistical Institute, Kolkata
Unni Krishnan, De Beers Group

Article Type

Research Article

Publication Title

Geological Journal

Abstract

We thank Patil Pillai et al. for preparing a critique on our article (Joy et al., 2018). Patil Pillai et al. contest the analytical procedure utilized for the carbonates and “geological information” documented in our research article and raise concerns on our conclusions. We hereby provide our reply to each of their comments.

First Page

3170

Last Page

3173

DOI

10.1002/gj.3546

Publication Date

9-1-2019

Comments

Open Access, Green

Recommended Citation

Joy, Sojen; Patranabis-Deb, Sarbani; Saha, Dilip; Jelsma, Hielke; Maas, Roland; Söderlund, Ulf; Tappe, Sebastian; van der Linde, Gert; Banerjee, Amlan; and Krishnan, Unni, "Reply to the comments by Pillai, S. P., George, B. G., Ray, J. S., and Kale, V. S., (GJ-19-0112) on Paper: “Depositional history and provenance of cratonic “Purana” basins in southern India: A multipronged geochronology approach to the Proterozoic Kaladgi and Bhima basins” by Joy et al., 2018" (2019). Journal Articles. 727.
https://digitalcommons.isical.ac.in/journal-articles/727